- This topic has 23 replies, 12 voices, and was last updated 8 years, 8 months ago by Manoj Kumar.
-
AuthorPosts
-
-
March 4, 2016 at 1:41 pm #31503Ranjeet KumarParticipant
Hi,
Can anybody explain What is threshold in BER analyzer.
And how it varies for different design.
here i am uploading image. -
March 4, 2016 at 9:47 pm #31541alistuParticipant
Hi Ranjeet,
The threshold is the value based on the received bits level compared to which the bit is detected. If the received bit amplitude is less than the threshold, the bit is detected as a logic “0”, and if the bit amplitude exceeds that of the threshold, the bit is detected as a logic “1”.
Regards
-
March 4, 2016 at 11:19 pm #31545Aabid BabaParticipant
Hi ranjeet,
For this you can make it analogous to operation of a simple digital switch. Alsitu rightly mentioned about the detection. If the received bit amplitude is below the threshold, the bit is detected as a logic “0”, and if the bit amplitude exceeds the threshold, the bit is detected as a logic “1”. I hope it helps.
Regards -
March 5, 2016 at 12:53 am #31564aasif bashir darParticipant
hi ranjeet,
threshold is very essential parameter to be set in the tranmission channel.if threshold is smaller, then there is great possiblity of heaving eerors in system because of noise power greater than threshold.
if threshold is larger, there is possibility of loss of bits(i.e again error) in reception, because bit power can be less than threshold becauese of channel attenuation.
thus threshold is to be optimized for minimum BER.
with regards
-
March 9, 2016 at 6:35 am #32037Ranjeet KumarParticipant
Thank you all,
But we could set threshold value. Which parameters decide what should be the value of threshold and how it varies. -
March 9, 2016 at 9:29 am #32055umer syedParticipant
HI RANJEET,
I THINK IT IS VERY MUCH VALID QUESTION AND COULD CONCEPT OF SETTING THE THRESHOLD FOR THE BER ANALYSISI GUESS WE COULD NOT SET THE THRESHOLD FOR BIT ERROR RATE ANALYSIS, THE THRESHOLD IS SET INHERENLTY BY THE ber ANALYZER.
WITH REGARDS
-
March 9, 2016 at 10:13 am #32066Aabid BabaParticipant
Hi Umer syed,
I could not understand your statement above. Do you mean we could set threshold for BER analysis ??
I guess it has to do with various parameters. Actually i have to design a threshold module myself for controlling power levels. I thought of asking you.
Regards
-
-
March 9, 2016 at 1:39 pm #32146Ranjeet KumarParticipant
thank you Umar sir for supporting and considering my problem and query.
-
March 12, 2016 at 12:06 pm #32569SAHIL SINGHParticipant
hi..
The threshold is the value based on the received bits level compared to which the bit is detected. If the received bit amplitude is less than the threshold, the bit is detected as a logic “0”, and if the bit amplitude exceeds that of the threshold, the bit is detected as a logic “1”.
but i also agree with naazira because the bits are taken to be equi-probable. i.e, bits 0 and 1 have equal probability of being transmitted
-
-
March 9, 2016 at 1:50 pm #32151aasif bashir darParticipant
hi aabid,
in your comment of #32066, you are intermingling the this post query and your power threshold query of your.
and how does the threshold varies with different parameters. can we set it??
hope you will reply soon.with regards
-
March 9, 2016 at 2:04 pm #32155Aabid BabaParticipant
Hi aasif,
I guess you are not understanding the context in which i had mentioned it. I have used interrogative marks at the end of the statement that means i am asking it not stating it and if you are confused then let me put it this way for you , Which parameters decide what should be the value of threshold ???
Who does calculate the threshold value here??
I hope you got my point now.. I hope you will reply..
Regards -
March 12, 2016 at 2:02 am #32533burhan num mina llahParticipant
Hi All
Aabid i also believe that your problem of designing the component to allow certain power levels above or below the threshold is different from what Ranjeet is asking, He wants to enquire about how to set threshold for the BER analyzer. I hope i had understood it correctly. As far as what Ranjeet is asking i am attaching a link below i hope u get to know how to set threshold as it shows how to calculate BER using a test set. And Aabid in your case u have to design a component as a whole i believe.
Best Regards
Burhan
-
March 12, 2016 at 4:01 am #32547Aabid BabaParticipant
hello Burhan num mina llah,
Thanks for replying. I understood what you are exactly referring to and rightly so. I was just asking if i could.
regards
-
-
March 12, 2016 at 2:28 am #32537Naazira BadarParticipant
Hi All..
Well threshold is no doubt a general concept.
But for the case of BER in communication theory, I beleive it is taken to be a mid-point , because the bits are taken to be equi-probable. i.e, bits 0 and 1 have equal probability of being transmitted. And at the Rx, if the amplitude is above mid-point, it is considered as 1 and if it is less than the mid-point value, it is considered as 0.And For Ranjeet, I would suggest you to post a screenshot of the BER Analyzer results where in there is some value. In the image you have attached, no data has been received or atleast detected. So not much can be inferred about how Optisystem has programmed the BER Analysis.
Regards.
-
March 12, 2016 at 5:03 am #32549Ranjeet KumarParticipant
Hi Naazira ma’m,
Here i am uploading the screenshots of BER analyzer with different values of Q-factor, Min. BER and others parameters as per your suggestions.
Now it would be easy to explain it further so that i could understand it better.-
March 17, 2016 at 1:19 pm #33050Mohamed Ben zegalamParticipant
Hi Ranjeet,
for the Capture10, as I can see the Q-factor is not mach the BER, please may you change the algorithm parameter to Gaussian instead of measuring. I think this will make the Q-factor mach the BER.
Thanks!
-
-
March 13, 2016 at 12:34 am #32588burhan num mina llahParticipant
Hello Aabid Baba
you are welcome. Productive discussions are always appreciated and discussion are overall productive i believe.
Ranjeet it seems to show the threshold values. Are u trying to ask that u want to edit this threshold value. then i believe it cannot be set in BER analyzer but it would be possible in the component ahead of that.Regards
Burhan
-
March 17, 2016 at 11:18 am #33047Naazira BadarParticipant
Hi Ranjeet..
I appreciate that you uploaded these. Going by these images, I think the concept of having a midpoint threshold value is actually about the last option of the table ‘Decision Inst.’. And about the threshold value, I can see there’s a difference in the two imaged. I believe this has to do with adaptive thresholding, wherein going by the channel state the threshold values are set to minimise the BER. This varies with the modulation schemes as well. Eg. OOK has fixed point thresholding. Could you please tell me which modulation scheme has been employed in the system ?
Regards.
-
March 19, 2016 at 3:32 pm #33218Ranjeet KumarParticipant
Hi Naazira Ma’m
The above image(10) is the screenshots of 4 user unidirectional OFDM system. The Ber analyzer shows its values of different parameters in downlink direction.
I have little idea about adaptive thresholding, Decision Inst. and the channel state the threshold values are set to minimise the BER.
If possible please explain the above points further or post links to explain it.
seeking for your response.
thank you -
March 19, 2016 at 3:35 pm #33219Ranjeet KumarParticipant
Hi Naazira Ma’m
The above image(10) is the screenshots of 4 user unidirectional OFDM PON system. The Ber analyzer shows its values of different parameters in downlink direction.
Here i am uploading the osd file of corresponding image and now expect some explanation from your side.
Seeking for your response. -
March 20, 2016 at 5:13 am #33272MHD NAParticipant
you can make it analogous to operation of a simple digital switch. Alsitu rightly mentioned about the detection. If the received bit amplitude is below the threshold, the bit is detected as a logic “0”, and if the bit amplitude exceeds the threshold, the bit is detected as a logic “1”. I hope it helps.
-
March 20, 2016 at 5:15 am #33273MHD NAParticipant
threshold is no doubt a general concept.
But for the case of BER in communication theory, I beleive it is taken to be a mid-point , because the bits are taken to be equi-probable. i.e, bits 0 and 1 have equal probability of being transmitted. And at the Rx, if the amplitude is above mid-point, it is considered as 1 and if it is less than the mid-point value, it is considered as 0.
And For Ranjeet, I would suggest you to post a screenshot of the BER Analyzer results where in there is some value. In the image you have attached, no data has been received or atleast detected. So not much can be inferred about how Optisystem has programmed the BER Analysis. -
March 20, 2016 at 5:31 am #33277FAYIQA NAQSHBANDISpectator
HI MHD
As mentioned in the other post that plz avoid copying and pasting the same comments..try adding something which maybe helpful to other members…i hope u refrain from it..
Thanks and regards -
April 11, 2016 at 7:09 am #36203Manoj KumarParticipant
Hi All..
Well threshold is no doubt a general concept.
But for the case of BER in communication theory, I beleive it is taken to be a mid-point , because the bits are taken to be equi-probable. i.e, bits 0 and 1 have equal probability of being transmitted. And at the Rx, if the amplitude is above mid-point, it is considered as 1 and if it is less than the mid-point value, it is considered as 0.And For Ranjeet, I would suggest you to post a screenshot of the BER Analyzer results where in there is some value. In the image you have attached, no data has been received or atleast detected. So not much can be inferred about how Optisystem has programmed the BER Analysis.
Regards
-
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.